Albert Einstein with Rabindranath Tagore

In the context of Holistic Quantum Relativity's Socratic Dialogue on ATCA and IntentBlog it is useful to note that the Nobel Laureates Prof Albert Einstein (1921) and Sir Rabindranath Tagore (1913) met at Einstein's residence in Berlin, Germany, on 14th July 1930, as photographed. The recorded conversation elegantly demonstrates how the two utilised the language of music, as a metaphor, to forge common ground between science & spirituality.

TAGORE: I was discussing with Dr Mendel [mutual friend] today the new mathematical discoveries which tell us that in the realm of infinitesimal atoms chance has its play; the drama of existence is not absolutely predestined in character.

EINSTEIN: The facts that make science tend toward this view do not say good-bye to causality.

TAGORE: Maybe not, yet it appears that the idea of causality is not in the elements, but that some other force builds up with them an organised universe.

EINSTEIN: One tries to understand in the higher plane how the order is. The order is there, where the big elements combine and guide existence, but in the minute elements this order is not perceptible.

TAGORE: Thus duality is in the depths of existence, the contradiction of free impulse and the directive will which works upon it and evolves an orderly scheme of things.

EINSTEIN: Modern physics would not say they are contradictory. Clouds look as one from a distance, but if you see them nearby, they show themselves as disorderly drops of water.

TAGORE: I find a parallel in human psychology. Our passions and desires are unruly, but our character subdues these elements into a harmonious whole. Does something similar to this happen in the physical world? Are the elements rebellious, dynamic with individual impulse? And is there a principle in the physical world which dominates them and puts them into an orderly organisation?

EINSTEIN: Even the elements are not without statistical order; elements of radium will always maintain their specific order, now and ever onward, just as they have done all along. There is, then, a statistical order in the elements.

TAGORE: Otherwise, the drama of existence would be too desultory. It is the constant harmony of chance and determination which makes it eternally new and living.

EINSTEIN: I believe that whatever we do or live for has its causality; it is good, however, that we cannot see through to it.

TAGORE: There is in human affairs an element of elasticity also, some freedom within a small range which is for the expression of our personality. It is like the musical system in India, which is not so rigidly fixed as western music. Our composers give a certain definite outline, a system of melody and rhythmic arrangement, and within a certain limit the player can improvise upon it. He must be one with the law of that particular melody, and then he can give spontaneous expression to his musical feeling within the prescribed regulation. We praise the composer for his genius in creating a foundation along with a superstructure of melodies, but we expect from the player his own skill in the creation of variations of melodic flourish and ornamentation. In creation we follow the central law of existence, but if we do not cut ourselves adrift from it, we can have sufficient freedom within the limits of our personality for the fullest self-expression.

EINSTEIN: That is possible only when there is a strong artistic tradition in music to guide the people's mind. In Europe, music has come too far away from popular art and popular feeling and has become something like a secret art with conventions and traditions of its own.

TAGORE: You have to be absolutely obedient to this too complicated music. In India, the measure of a singer's freedom is in his own creative personality. He can sing the composer's song as his own, if he has the power creatively to assert himself in his interpretation of the general law of the melody which he is given to interpret.

EINSTEIN: It requires a very high standard of art to realize fully the great idea in the original music, so that one can make variations upon it. In our country, the variations are often prescribed.

TAGORE: If in our conduct we can follow the law of goodness, we can have real liberty of self-expression. The principle of conduct is there, but the character which makes it true and individual is our own creation. In our music there is a duality of freedom and prescribed order.

EINSTEIN: Are the words of a song also free? I mean to say, is the singer at liberty to add his own words to the song which he is singing?

TAGORE: Yes. In Bengal we have a kind of song-kirtan, we call it -- which gives freedom to the singer to introduce parenthetical comments, phrases not in the original song. This occasions great enthusiasm, since the audience is constantly thrilled by some beautiful, spontaneous sentiment added by the singer.

EINSTEIN: Is the metrical form quite severe?

TAGORE: Yes, quite. You cannot exceed the limits of versification; the singer in all his variations must keep the rhythm and the time, which is fixed. In European music you have a comparative liberty with time, but not with melody.

EINSTEIN: Can the Indian music be sung without words? Can one understand a song without words?

TAGORE: Yes, we have songs with unmeaning words, sounds which just help to act as carriers of the notes. In North India, music is an independent art, not the interpretation of words and thoughts, as in Bengal. The music is very intricate and subtle and is a complete world of melody by itself.

EINSTEIN: Is it not polyphonic?

TAGORE: Instruments are used, not for harmony, but for keeping time and adding to the volume and depth. Has melody suffered in your music by the imposition of harmony?

EINSTEIN: Sometimes it does suffer very much. Sometimes the harmony swallows up the melody altogether.

TAGORE: Melody and harmony are like lines and colours in pictures. A simple linear picture may be completely beautiful; the introduction of colour may make it vague and insignificant. Yet colour may, by combination with lines, create great pictures, so long as it does not smother and destroy their value.

EINSTEIN: It is a beautiful comparison; line is also much older than colour. It seems that your melody is much richer in structure than ours. Japanese music also seems to be so.

TAGORE: It is difficult to analyze the effect of eastern and western music on our minds. I am deeply moved by the western music; I feel that it is great, that it is vast in its structure and grand in its composition. Our own music touches me more deeply by its fundamental lyrical appeal. European music is epic in character; it has a broad background and is Gothic in its structure.

EINSTEIN: This is a question we Europeans cannot properly answer, we are so used to our own music. We want to know whether our own music is a conventional or a fundamental human feeling, whether to feel consonance and dissonance is natural, or a convention which we accept.

TAGORE: Somehow the piano confounds me. The violin pleases me much more.

EINSTEIN: It would be interesting to study the effects of European music on an Indian who had never heard it when he was young.

TAGORE: Once I asked an English musician to analyze for me some classical music, and explain to me what elements make for the beauty of the piece.

EINSTEIN: The difficulty is that the really good music, whether of the East or of the West, cannot be analyzed.

TAGORE: Yes, and what deeply affects the hearer is beyond himself.

EINSTEIN: The same uncertainty will always be there about everything fundamental in our experience, in our reaction to art, whether in Europe or in Asia. Even the red flower I see before me on your table may not be the same to you and me.

TAGORE: And yet there is always going on the process of reconciliation between them, the individual taste conforming to the universal standard.


45 Responses to “Albert Einstein with Rabindranath Tagore”

Anonymous said...
March 22, 2013 at 5:02 PM

This design іs steller! You dеfinitely know how
to κeep a гeаder entertained. Between your
wit anԁ youг vіԁeos, I ωaѕ almοѕt moѵеd to start my οwn blog (well, almοѕt.
..HaHa!) Great ϳob. I rеally loveԁ what you had to say, anԁ
moгe than thаt, how уou prеsenteԁ it.
Too cοοl!

mу weblog; Chemietoilette

Anonymous said...
March 27, 2013 at 8:15 AM

Eνen low eaгnings that Proffer A-Z lists οf tro choi to chоose from.
One of the numbeг one biz Present, What's My course? began in 1950 and ran on to Deal lease your children Represent Dora the Explorer Disembarrass tro choi. Forfend spamming Marines, festival discounts on On-line biz stores.

my homepage; game

Anonymous said...
March 28, 2013 at 8:36 AM

For the reason that the admin of this site is
working, no hesitation very shortly it will be famous, due to its feature

Look into my web blog ... server dreambox

Anonymous said...
March 30, 2013 at 3:29 PM

This sweater comes in many colors ranging from ivory to black and
also comes in sizes from small to XXL in men's. The soft sweater is made from a high quality lightweight wool jersey blend and features allover topstitching. The brand has sustained the time testing any brand goes through over the decades thanks to mouth-publicity it receives.

Here is my site: sweater polos

Anonymous said...
April 4, 2013 at 1:01 AM

Тhis pοst is invaluable. When can I
find out mοrе?

My web sіte:

Anonymous said...
April 5, 2013 at 3:14 AM

The сheese would be melted anԁ bubbly, but most effectіve of all the toppings wоuld
nοt be burnt. - Cеntre tunnel сhimney duct tο maхimiѕe economicаl warm aіrflow.
A cοmpletе gгain breakfast
of оutԁated-fаshіoned oatmeal ωіth almonԁs (gгind them up to disguіsе them, if obligatоry) ωill κeep а kid ωay a bіt longer than orаnge juісe
and a bagel.

my ωеb pagе ... what is the best material for pizza stones

Anonymous said...
April 7, 2013 at 8:12 AM

Home mole removal can work well for those who have moles that bother them as long as
the are not a typical moles. After all, they can be readily sourced from the internet.
Others think tanning and sunning themselves will dry up their skin and pimples to eliminate their acne.

Also visit my blog post ... Scar removal

Anonymous said...
April 16, 2013 at 12:07 AM

I like thе valuable іnfo уou suρply on уоur
articles. I'll bookmark your blog and test once more here frequently. I'm гаther ceгtain I'll learn lots of new stuff proper here! Best of luck for the next!

Feel free to visit my blog: augen lasern

Anonymous said...
May 7, 2013 at 5:00 AM

Nice post. I learn something new and challenging on websites I stumbleupon everyday.
It's always useful to read articles from other writers and practice something from other sites.

My blog post: Art:Photography

Anonymous said...
May 12, 2013 at 3:09 PM

Υou should take part in a cοnteѕt for one οf the most uѕeful websites οn the web.
I most cеrtаinly will гecοmmenԁ
thіs sitе!

Feel frеe to surf to my ωeblog

Anonymous said...
May 13, 2013 at 12:52 PM

I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you design
this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you?
Plz answer back as I'm looking to construct my own blog and would like to know where u got this from. kudos

Feel free to visit my site :: Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet

Anonymous said...
May 14, 2013 at 2:31 PM

Hi, I do believe this is an excellent blog.
I stumbledupon it ;) I'm going to revisit once again since I book-marked it. Money and freedom is the greatest way to change, may you be rich and continue to guide other people.

Visit my weblog Fotografia

Anonymous said...
May 21, 2013 at 2:37 PM

I visited multiple websites however the audio feature for audio
songs present at this web page is in fact

Here is my web-site; Fotografia

Anonymous said...
May 24, 2013 at 9:15 PM

An outstanding shаre! I have just forwaгded
this ontο a сoworkег who was conducting a little homewοrk on this.
And he аctually bοught me bгeaκfаst
becauѕe I stumblеԁ upοn іt for
him... lol. Ѕo аllow mе to reword this.
... Thank YOU for the meal!! But уeah, thanks
for spending the tіmе to discuѕs this issuе herе on
yοur blog.

Fееl free to suгf to mу websitе Lloyd Irvin

Anonymous said...
May 25, 2013 at 9:14 AM

Thanks very interesting blog!

my web page - Wedding photography

Anonymous said...
May 28, 2013 at 3:54 AM

Heya і'm for the first time here. I came across this board and I find It really useful & it helped me out a lot. I hope to give something back and help others like you helped me.

Here is my webpage ... crear facebook

Scott Waring said...
May 16, 2015 at 9:00 PM

Very cool post, thanks for this.

Stanley Workman said...
February 21, 2016 at 5:33 AM

Recently, I had the honor of working collaboratively with the astrophysics lab at Case Western Reserve University in taking a series of deep space images. The field had been having difficulty in filtering out the static found prevalent thus far. The resultant photos which interpret what telescopes were seeing, seem to be causing quite a stir in both the fine art and astronomy circles.
Please refer to my LinkedIn profile, for further biographical data. -Marc Breed, Fine Artist

fashion shoes said...
September 15, 2016 at 11:35 PM

very nice article,keep sharing!!!.

some of the best mens shoes available here
oxford shoes online in India

Muhammad said...
May 13, 2018 at 3:50 AM

This is such an informative post. You have a lot of really great points. I wish I had this post as a resource when I started blogging.
Telescope Price in UAE .

sam krik said...
September 25, 2018 at 2:14 AM

If you want to Setup your office product visit office

sam krik said...
December 3, 2018 at 11:31 PM

Installing your Microsoft Office365 may be you can see the message like, Stop, you should wait to install Office

Rose helly said...
January 7, 2019 at 11:00 PM

We are providing a step by step guide to set up Office along with independent support service for installation and activation issues.

Post a Comment

Thanks for you decided to share something :)